Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic movie
   Criticizing James Cameron's Film

Browsing this Thread:   133 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  1 Votes
  •  Johno
      Johno
Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film
#1

Joined: 2005/2/13
From Scotland
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
The whole cult regarding Titanic has struck me as quite odd. Bob Ballard and his team discovered the wreck some 15 years ago now, and I remember reading avidly the articles and speculation about the tradegy. Its funny how there wasn't a Titanic phenomenom then; it takes a slushy film with a fictional romance to create any impact.

If "Titanic" was moving it was because of the fiction, not the fact. It was a story about doomed love on some ship that sank 87 years ago. I just thought it was rather tasteless. I thought "A night to remember" was a much more sensitive and moving film; I wasn't bothered by model shots and historical and technical accuracy. Cameron's film might have been accurate, but it didn't communicate the reality of 1500 drowned individuals.

As someone who has always been interested in the tradegy.. I find the whole cult surrounding this film very disturbing. Why wasn't there all this interest 15 years ago? It will be interesting to see what future cultural historians make of this record-grossing film... I'm certainly baffled by its success.

Posted on: 2005/3/3 16:36
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/2/22 17:04
       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/2/23 8:49
         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/2/26 12:05
           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/2/26 21:45
             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/2/27 12:10
     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film ReefBlue 2005/2/27 15:46
       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/2/28 10:38
         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film am_vanquish 2005/2/28 19:23
           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/3/3 16:36
             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Isambard 2005/3/4 21:26
               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/3/8 8:04
                 Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/5/14 20:32
                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film edward9139 2005/5/15 12:18
                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/17 9:38
                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/5/17 18:22
                         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/18 8:38
                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film edward9139 2005/5/18 10:54
                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/5/18 16:33
                               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/5/18 17:06
                                 Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film edward9139 2005/5/20 10:24
                                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/20 11:22
                                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/20 12:54
                                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/5/21 18:01
                                         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/5/21 18:20
                                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/25 8:24
                                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film GooseGrl172 2005/5/26 23:45
                                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Captain_Jack 2005/5/27 1:50
                                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/27 12:51
                                               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/5/27 19:11
                                                 Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/5/28 10:30
                                                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Kyle J. W. 2005/9/16 1:39
                                                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Jillian 2005/9/16 22:17
                                                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/9/16 23:13
                                                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film louise 2005/9/17 4:20
                                                         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TCB83 2005/9/19 1:03
                                                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/9/24 18:31
                                                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film camelogarmel 2005/9/25 4:23
                                                               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Jillian 2005/10/3 23:59
                                                                 Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film camelogarmel 2005/10/4 1:31
                                                                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Jillian 2005/10/4 2:38
                                                                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/10/5 18:39
                                                                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/10/25 0:43
                                                                         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film roseflower 2005/10/25 16:27
                                                                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Kyle J. W. 2005/10/26 2:11
                                                                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/10/27 19:29
                                                                               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/10/27 21:11
                                                                                 Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Martyn 2005/10/27 22:02
                                                                                   Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/10/28 20:22
                                                                                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/10/28 20:32
                                                                                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film Johno 2005/10/28 21:14
                                                                                         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/10/28 21:16
                                                                                           Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film clinton 2005/10/30 9:50
                                                                                             Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film roseflower 2005/11/1 11:14
                                                                                               Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/11/4 17:55
                                                                                     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film GooseGrl172 2005/11/5 17:06
                                                                                       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/11/5 20:35
     Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film GooseGrl172 2005/11/4 22:10
       Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film TITANICsoul 2005/11/5 1:54
         Re: Criticizing James Cameron's Film roseflower 2005/11/5 8:57
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box