Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic movie
   Did Jack really love Rose?

Browsing this Thread:   1690 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  64 Votes
Re: Did Jack really love Rose?
#1

Joined: 2004/8/3
From Tallmadge, Ohio
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Quote:

Jillian wrote:
One of the points of this movie was to show that time doesn't measure love! It shows veiwers that you really can fall in love in short period of time. It does not matter! Love isn't something that is built, it's just something that is there. Some people don't beleive in soulmates but I do and that's what Jack and Rose were! They were destined to be together.


No, I don't agree with that. They didn't use jack and Rose to prove anything with love.. it's not a love story.. they neede Rose and Jack to tie first and third class together in the story so they had an actual plot, and not just a story about a sinking ship.

And, I didn't say you had to know everyone's faults or wrong doings.. I was merely pointing out that to be in true love, you have to know those things about somoene and still accept them for who they are.... that's why so many peopole divorce within the first year of marriage, because they can't deal with those things.

I also think it's obvious you've never been in love, or else you'd know that.
To be in love with someone is different than just loving them... TOTALLY different.. and I know people will disagree with that on here.. but, hoenstly, once they experience both, thy'll understad what I mean.
I think you are just falling in love with the romanticism of the movie, which is totally understandable and completely fine.

I also want to point out, you are right to an extent. I do think people fall in love in diffrent time spans... but I do think there IS a time span. I don't think you can fall in love till you're past the puppy love.... I'd say about 3-6 months is past puppylove.
3 days gets you puppylove and lust... and intrigue....

OH! And he let her have the door because he may have been poor, but he was a cordial gentleman....It was proper for man to ensure a woman's safety first.. even though alot of men forgot that on that night, he didn't....
I mean, she was already on it when he found out he couldn't get on.. what's he gunna do, flip it and make her get off it? I think not.




And love definately is something that is built. People in some cultures, and in most past cultures were married in prearranged marriages.... even though they had never met each other prior to their wedding day, they were set for life.. and often times, ende dup loving each other after a period of time. So, it CAN be built, and it CAN just click for some people. It did for jack and Rose, but i refuse to believe they were madtly in love with each other.. they were just infatuated with each other at that point.
_________________
I'm not Kate Winslet OR Rose DeWitt Bukater.... please stop sending me fan mail!

My Website.. Titanic: Truth, Myths and Legends
Posted on: 2005/8/10 2:05
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/4/17 21:01
       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? picard1701 2005/4/17 21:12
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Dominican12 2005/4/17 21:44
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/4/18 16:48
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? clinton 2005/4/19 12:53
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Titanic65 2005/10/5 22:01
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/10/6 23:14
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/10/6 23:50
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/10/7 10:09
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/10/7 14:45
                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? RoseDawson37 2005/10/14 23:12
                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/10/28 16:03
                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? clinton 2005/11/3 15:14
                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/11/4 0:24
                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? clinton 2005/11/5 15:28
                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/11/5 16:01
                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/11/5 16:07
                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/11/5 20:38
                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/11/5 22:04
                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/11/6 3:39
                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Dominican12 2005/11/6 3:41
                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/11/6 3:55
                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? rose_titanic 2005/12/6 1:45
                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? clinton 2005/12/6 10:21
                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/12/6 18:58
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? annie242 2005/4/19 18:24
       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/4/19 19:32
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/4/20 18:46
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Dominican12 2005/4/21 20:34
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/4/22 1:46
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Captain_Jack 2005/4/25 22:26
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/4/26 11:09
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Anonymous 2005/4/26 11:14
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? lucus 2006/8/6 2:34
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? jacknrose 2006/8/7 3:32
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? ImaTitanicluvr 2006/8/7 19:45
                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? kell 2006/9/17 22:05
                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Downward78 2006/9/18 4:21
                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Downward78 2006/9/18 4:33
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Mac G 2007/5/5 16:31
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? <3 2007/6/22 12:53
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2010/4/15 10:52
       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Anonymous 2005/4/26 11:30
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/4/27 11:11
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/4/27 18:11
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/4/30 18:46
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Captain_Jack 2005/5/1 22:54
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/2 0:34
                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/2 14:26
                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Lisa_1114 2005/5/3 12:30
                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Delphiscn 2005/5/3 14:15
                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/3 15:55
                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/4 10:51
                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/4 16:03
                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/6 1:05
                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/6 10:54
                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/6 10:55
                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Nephrilim 2005/5/9 1:40
                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/9 10:25
                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/9 10:32
                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/9 10:39
                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/9 17:40
                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/9 19:42
                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/10 1:11
                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/10 10:32
                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/5/10 11:50
                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/5/10 17:59
                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/5/10 20:12
                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? clinton 2005/5/11 13:12
                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/3 20:56
                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/4 3:13
                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/4 3:47
                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2005/8/4 4:52
                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/4 13:54
                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/4 14:42
                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/4 14:50
                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? donkey 2005/8/4 20:21
                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/4 23:04
                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/5 2:52
                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/8/5 17:17
                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/5 18:40
                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/6 3:32
                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/8 18:12
                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/8 22:53
                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/8 23:46
                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Yaya123 2005/8/9 16:23
                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/9 17:34
                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/9 20:05
                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/9 21:42
                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/10 2:05
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/10 15:56
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/11 3:45
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Yaya123 2005/8/12 9:32
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/12 13:50
                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/12 19:13
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/12 23:49
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/13 0:32
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/13 5:45
                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/13 16:38
                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/13 19:53
                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/13 20:10
                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/13 22:09
                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/14 0:23
                                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/14 1:19
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Yaya123 2005/9/3 5:19
                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/5 17:13
                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/8/4 20:20
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/14 3:37
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/14 7:07
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/14 13:50
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/14 14:18
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/14 21:28
                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/14 21:38
                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/14 22:28
                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/15 1:07
                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/15 1:16
                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/15 1:26
                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/15 1:36
                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Kyle J. W. 2005/8/15 1:58
                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/15 2:03
                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/15 2:19
                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/15 2:30
                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/15 2:35
                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/15 2:44
                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/15 2:58
                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? sylvester_1 2005/8/15 17:49
                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/15 21:50
                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/15 22:40
                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/18 3:42
                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? edward9139 2005/8/18 14:22
                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/18 16:55
                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/21 20:57
                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/21 21:53
                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/21 22:06
                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/21 22:08
                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/22 7:58
                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/22 18:05
                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/8/22 22:41
                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/22 22:57
                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/23 16:05
                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 16:49
                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/23 16:51
                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 16:55
                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/23 17:05
                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 17:21
                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/23 17:28
                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 17:29
                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Johno 2005/8/23 17:59
                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/23 21:16
                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/23 21:41
                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 21:59
                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/23 22:10
                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 22:24
                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/23 23:31
                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/23 23:37
                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/25 5:05
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/25 7:27
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/25 15:55
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Martyn 2005/8/25 18:04
                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/25 22:06
                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/26 13:39
                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/28 2:19
                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/28 7:06
                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/8/28 14:04
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/28 14:15
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/8/28 14:19
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/28 19:55
                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? GooseGrl172 2005/8/28 20:49
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/8/28 21:27
                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/29 15:46
                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Dominican12 2005/8/29 18:29
                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/8/29 22:59
                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/29 23:10
                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Darian89 2005/8/29 23:24
                                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/29 23:28
                                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/30 1:34
                                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? titanic_boy 2005/8/30 8:55
                                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/30 9:56
                                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/8/30 15:51
                                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/8/31 1:04
                                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/1 16:51
                                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/9/1 19:54
                                                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/1 21:54
                                                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? 2007 gangsta gurrrrl 2005/9/2 10:42
                                                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/9/2 14:17
                                                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 16:01
                                                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 16:04
                                                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 16:10
                                                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 16:16
                                                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 16:20
                                                                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 16:42
                                                                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 16:46
                                                                                                                                               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 16:54
                                                                                                                                                 Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 16:56
                                                                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 16:59
                                                                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 17:01
                                                                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicCrazy 2005/9/2 17:08
                                                                                                                                                   Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/9/2 17:25
                                                                                                                                                     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 17:37
                                                                                                                                                       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/9/2 17:49
                                                                                                                                                         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 18:15
                                                                                                                                                           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? NosieRosie 2005/9/2 18:32
                                                                                                                                                             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Jillian 2005/9/2 18:38
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TitanicxLove 2005/9/17 19:27
       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? marecadtitanic 2006/10/7 3:57
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Knorr 2006/11/5 0:14
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? anne elise 2006/11/11 1:55
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? boats752 2005/12/7 10:47
       Re: Jack Truly Loved Rose missamerica 2006/7/25 20:20
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Angel85 2006/8/1 14:40
       Re: Did Jack really love Rose? TITANICsoul 2007/1/13 8:27
         Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Katie Luvs Titanic 2007/2/11 18:23
           Re: Did Jack really love Rose? gal of titanic 2007/2/12 23:01
             Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Titanic98 2007/4/7 16:30
               Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Captain Dan 2007/4/9 18:35
         Who Is "Kate Buckley?" Bluemax45 2010/5/10 16:51
           Re: Who Is "Kate Buckley?" Bluemax45 2010/7/27 2:09
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? levi vaughn 2007/4/9 20:31
     Re: Did Jack really love Rose? Kathi 2007/4/10 18:44
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box