Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic historic
   Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner?

Browsing this Thread:   167 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  1 Votes
  •  Captain_Jack
      Captain_Jack
Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner?
#1

Joined: 2005/3/30
From
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Quote:

Mark Chirnside wrote:
Quote:

clinton wrote:
Because they left the binoculars and extra lifeboats ashore.


Hello,

There's no evidence that the binoculars were left ashore, and in any case my post above indicates some of the debate around the binoculars. There's much to question, and consider whether that debate is a 'red herring.' As for extra lifeboats, why would there be any additional lifeboats ashore prior to the disaster, when the requirement for additional lifeboat capacity was not apparent?

Best wishes,

Mark.


All the binoculars and lifevests in the world would not have saved the Titanic. Nobody will ever know for sure why the iceburg was not spotted earlier. Chances are the berg was nothing more than a growler and it could not have been seen till they were right on it. It's really a dead subject "why". If they had the binoculars would they have used them, were the lookouts engaged in conversation or even not paying attention at all! I have been on the Mississippi when ice flows break up and even on smaller water its easy to overlook ice flows 5 feet tall in darkness. Faith decided Titanic would sink and by God she did. Don't tempt God by declairing that "God himself can't sink that ship".
Posted on: 2005/5/11 17:53
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? glen_fitzger 2005/4/26 23:42
       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Captain_Jack 2005/4/27 20:31
       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/11 12:09
     Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Sealord 2005/5/10 14:55
       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Johno 2005/5/10 18:14
         Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Sealord 2005/5/11 0:35
           Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? edward9139 2005/5/11 1:36
       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/11 12:11
         Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? clinton 2005/5/11 13:28
           Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/11 13:38
             Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Captain_Jack 2005/5/11 17:53
               Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Jeffro 2005/5/12 10:19
                 Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/12 12:08
                   Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Jeffro 2005/5/12 12:20
                     Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/12 13:18
                       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? edward9139 2005/5/13 10:20
                         Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/13 10:36
                           Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? edward9139 2005/5/13 10:43
                             Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/13 10:56
                               Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? edward9139 2005/5/13 11:01
                                 Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/13 11:03
                                   Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Martyn 2005/5/13 11:27
                                     Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/13 11:31
                                       Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? edward9139 2005/5/13 15:05
                                         Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Mark Chirnside 2005/5/13 15:13
                                           Re: Why didn't the crew see the iceberg sooner? Martyn 2005/5/28 14:21
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box