Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic historic
   What if it hit it head on?

Browsing this Thread:   112 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  1 Votes
  •  WSLHistorian
      WSLHistorian
Re: What if it hit it head on?
#1

Joined: 2005/7/24
From United States
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Interesting questions on the possibility of Titanic hitting the iceberg with her stern instead of the bow. Depending on how she hit the berg with her stern there's the possibility that not as much damage would have occured. Being that you have on each side two propeller shafts and in the middle another propeller and a rudder that some exclaimed to be the size of a giant elm tree, there's a chance that if she did strike the berg from the stern that their "might" not have been as much damage caused to the area below the water line. If this senerio would of occured she would most likely have damage yes, but no where near as severe as a strike on the bow. She'd be still in a very bad situation with her propeller's damaged or engine area flooding but she may have floated longer of possibly just had minor flooding.

The events by 1st Officer Murdoch on the bridge are what made Titanic's fate sealed. He did correct by ordering Quartermaster Hitchens to turn the ship "hard-a-starboard" but by reversing the engines he caused a burbling effect in the water, causing there to be no clean or smooth water going by Titanic's rudder. (compare this to stiring a bucket of water with a big spoon...keep stiring really fast until you get a whirlpool effect...then stop and begin to turn in the opposite direction...the water gets choppy and doesn't know where to go). This gives you a idea of what happened when he ordered the propellers to reverse after going at about 21 knots. If he had just said full speed ahead and hard-a-starboard...its very likely they would have missed the iceberg. They only sideswiped it in the first place... just a little more and they would have likely cleared the berg and any of it that remained under the waterline.
_________________
Mark Passwaters
Posted on: 2005/7/24 15:16
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: What if it hit it head on? roseflower 2005/6/7 12:06
       Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/6/7 15:48
       Re: What if it hit it head on? Anonymous 2005/6/8 19:42
         Re: What if it hit it head on? xlostxboix 2005/6/8 23:01
           Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/6/9 1:01
             Re: What if it hit it head on? 401fanatic 2005/6/10 12:21
               Re: What if it hit it head on? ASL3207 2005/6/10 13:35
                 Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/6/11 10:15
                   Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/6/11 12:14
                     Re: What if it hit it head on? TitanicCrazy 2005/6/11 18:59
                       Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/6/11 20:17
                         Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/6/25 14:20
                           Re: What if it hit it head on? Titanic65 2005/7/4 5:37
                             Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/4 16:34
                               Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/5 13:24
                                 Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/5 14:38
                                   Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/5 16:19
                                     Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/5 18:36
                                       Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/6 12:46
                   Re: What if it hit it head on? lej86 2005/6/27 22:43
                     Re: What if it hit it head on? DoohanOK 2005/6/28 3:55
                       Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/6/28 14:18
                         Re: What if it hit it head on? DoohanOK 2005/6/29 10:52
                           Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/6/29 12:39
                             Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/6/29 21:51
                               Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/1 13:23
     Re: What if it hit it head on? satcher14 2005/7/11 4:42
       Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/18 23:31
         Re: What if it hit it head on? riotgirl1997 2005/7/19 3:13
           Re: What if it hit it head on? TitanicCrazy 2005/7/19 20:50
             Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/19 20:51
               Re: What if it hit it head on? TitanicCrazy 2005/7/19 20:56
                 Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/19 20:59
                   Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/20 12:00
                     Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/20 12:10
                       Re: What if it hit it head on? edward9139 2005/7/20 12:25
                     Re: What if it hit it head on? nightharlem 2005/7/21 5:21
                       Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/21 11:23
                         Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/7/21 12:05
                           Re: What if it hit it head on? TitanicCrazy 2005/7/21 12:15
                             Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/22 16:17
                               Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/7/22 17:29
                                 Re: What if it hit it head on? TitanicCrazy 2005/7/22 18:02
                                   Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/7/22 19:16
                                     Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/22 22:39
                                 Re: What if it hit it head on? motery 2005/7/23 4:37
                                   Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/7/24 13:36
                 Re: What if it hit it head on? nightharlem 2005/7/21 5:18
     Re: What if it hit it head on? WSLHistorian 2005/7/24 15:16
       Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/7/24 16:13
         Re: What if it hit it head on? WSLHistorian 2005/7/24 16:35
     Re: What if it hit it head on? Brian 2005/7/26 22:33
       Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2005/7/27 1:17
         Re: What if it hit it head on? WSLHistorian 2005/7/27 3:05
           Re: What if it hit it head on? Johno 2005/8/5 17:13
             Re: What if it hit it head on? Dan 2006/8/3 0:52
             Re: What if it hit it head on? Martyn 2006/8/3 2:20
               Re: What if it hit it head on? rip1912 2006/8/3 3:22
                 Re: What if it hit it head on? Cody123 2006/8/25 19:11
                   Re: What if it hit it head on? MGY Friend 2006/8/25 23:20
                     Re: What if it hit it head on? jacknrose 2006/8/29 4:21
                       Re: What if it hit it head on? xkitten14x 2006/8/31 17:56
                         Re: What if it hit it head on? S.A.M. 2006/8/31 18:44
                           Re: What if it hit it head on? MGY Friend 2006/8/31 20:21
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box