Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic Biographical research
   Titanic can't be raised from the bottom

Browsing this Thread:   32 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread
  •  GooseGrl172
      GooseGrl172
Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom
#1

Joined: 2004/10/11
From Maryland
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Well I wouldn't call my comments a report, it was a pretty general statement. And I take no offense, if I'm wrong, I'm wrong! But it's good to have a nice stimulating conversation.

Actually when I mention the hydrodynamic forces (or fluid dynamic really), I was speaking more of the amount of drag and turbulant flow that would be created due to all the obstructions, the "lift" force (I don't know what it would be called in hydrodynamics) that would be placed on it, at the angle and manor at which the ship would have to be brought up, and the pressure differences of the water flowing around the wreck as it would be lifted. Is this what you are saying would be to a lesser degree due to the depths (and temperature especially)? I agree with this, but we would be trying to lift the Titanic to the surface, which means these would all be changing. All of these forces are quite violent, even at a small number. I guess if it were all taken into very careful consideration, than possibly it would be done.

What you are saying does make sense, and I understand the affect the colder temperature would have (Brownian), but how would I go about applying these equations to Titanic's wreck? How would I take into account the effect all the obstructions, debries and overall state, shape and angle the ship is brought up at? Since all of these things are pretty much unknowns (to me anyway), and there are no models to work with that I know of. I suppose I could at best, use Titanic's plans and do calculations based upon those. That would be a load of work, very difficult. Too large a scale for me to take on anytime in the near future lol.

I know I can't be wrong in saying that these forces played a huge roll in the destruction of the ship on the way down. It's why I'm not surprised the stern looks the way it does (excluding the air that was still trapped inside, which also caused destruction). Because of the way the stern fell (and it's weight), it encountered these forces to a greater degree than the bow section (which is more hydrodynamic, the way it fell, and it was already mostly filled with water).

I admittedly don't know much about hydrodynamics, I do know about aerodynamics though. I know that the forces encountered here, are very similar in the water (and are greatly magnified), and are very violent, which is how I came to my theory. Maybe that was a stupid assumption.

As for spelling, don't worry, this is the internet.

Also, could I trouble you to translate these forces (those that apply) from aerdynamic terms to hydrodynamic terms? Just a few simple abbreviations are ok.

Thanks, so much
Jessica
Posted on: 2005/11/19 0:56
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/13 1:19
       Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Dominican12 2005/11/15 11:59
         Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Jillian 2005/11/15 20:38
           Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/15 21:20
             Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Jillian 2005/11/15 22:33
               Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/15 22:35
                 Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Martyn 2005/11/16 19:11
                   Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/16 23:34
                     Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Dominican12 2005/11/17 5:50
                       Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/17 18:17
                   Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/17 20:53
                     Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/17 22:04
                       Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/17 22:44
                         Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom Dominican12 2005/11/18 4:32
                           Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/18 5:57
                             Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/18 10:52
                               Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/18 16:15
                               Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom GooseGrl172 2005/11/18 17:00
                                 Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/18 18:27
                                   Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/18 18:58
                                     Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom GooseGrl172 2005/11/19 0:56
                                       Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom TITANICsoul 2005/11/19 2:39
                                         Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/19 12:54
                                           Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom GooseGrl172 2005/11/19 17:21
                                             Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/19 17:42
                                               Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom GooseGrl172 2005/11/19 18:28
                                                 Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom S-Park 2005/11/19 19:01
                     Re: Titanic can't be raised from the bottom GooseGrl172 2005/11/18 16:56
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box