Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic news
   Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful?

Browsing this Thread:   59 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  2 Votes
  •  Captain Dan
      Captain Dan
Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful?
#1

Joined: 2007/3/27
From Maryland, United States
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Debating about raising the ship is folly; it won't happen. If we really need to have an Olympic class liner raised, why not Britannic, which isn't a grave site? That ship is preserved far better Titanic. I don't personally feel that we need to raise that one either, but that may actually be possible, while the Titanic is beyond hope of ever seeing the light of day again.

Back to the OP, I'm rather torn. Filming it keeps the memory of those lost alive for generations that would otherwise have forgotten them. It reminds us of the tragic end which befell them and in a way is a memorial in itself, as it continues to tell their story. On the other hand, it seems that as a grave site, it should receive more respect.

Removing objects from the wreckage is just plain wrong. While I do agree with Danny J about the body being simply a shell, those bodies house people who were loved and cared for. Who were mourned when the ship went down. The families of the lost fully expected that the ship would remain a grave for them and be honoured as such. The finding of the ship allowed those families some sense of closure. Disturbing the wreck by removing artifacts from it is disrespectful to those families.

I understand the desire for relics; they allow us to touch a piece of the past. But the Titanic is gone and her passengers (those who didn't get rescued) are dead. Let them rest.

Daniel
Posted on: 2007/4/3 17:37
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? S.A.M. 2007/1/24 21:50
       Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Ema423 2007/1/25 0:49
         Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? crust2006 2007/2/22 12:35
           Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? rip1912 2007/2/22 14:07
             Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? MGY Friend 2007/2/22 14:29
               Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? gal of titanic 2007/2/22 23:30
                 Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? crust2006 2007/2/24 16:18
                   Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? jacknrose 2007/2/25 3:54
                     Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? h2oclub 2007/2/26 6:51
               Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Bea Kratz2 2007/3/8 21:23
                 Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Titanic King 2007/3/10 3:55
     Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Danny J 2007/2/26 20:32
       Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? MGY Friend 2007/2/26 20:56
         Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Danny J 2007/2/27 0:37
           Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? h2oclub 2007/2/27 1:25
             Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Danny J 2007/2/27 20:27
               Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? MGY Friend 2007/2/27 22:06
               Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Mrs. Andrews 2007/4/3 11:59
                 Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Captain Dan 2007/4/3 17:37
                   Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? MGY Friend 2007/4/3 18:48
                     Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? kurt w 2007/4/11 0:34
                       Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Rowan 2007/4/11 1:32
                         Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? Mrs. Andrews 2007/4/11 12:15
                           Re: Is filming the Titanic wreck disrespectful? MGY Friend 2007/4/11 14:52
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box