Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic historic
   Titanic and the Californian

Browsing this Thread:   51 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  5 Votes
  •  Mac G
      Mac G
Re: Titanic and the Californian
#1

Joined: 2007/4/15
From New York
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Quote:

Buff Egan wrote:
Most experts estimate the Californian was between 4 and 8 miles away. Both the Titanic and Californain could see each others lights. the Big problem I have with Lord is why he didn't wake up Evans. Lord never Captained another Ship after the Titanic Disaster.


-No. That's false I do believe. What experts have said 4-8 miles away? I'd like to see some facts on that. The link I posted goes through a lot of details on where they lie and none leans towards anything that close.

-Yes, they could see each other's lights, we've been through that.

-Why didn't Lord wake Evans? Probably because Stone told him only of one rocket and not they were throwing stars. He never suggested distress even though he may have felt it. Perhaps if he was more convincing and descriptive, Lord would have came to the bridge or had Evans woken to investigate on the "white rockets." It wasn't until Stewart suggested to do so after 5am that Evans was woken.

-You believe it was rightfully so that they should have been make a scapegoat? Do you know what a scapegoat is? That means they are being blaming in place of others mistakes and wrong doings. Like instead of blaming the Board of Trade for not having enough boats or the White Star Line for not conducting boat drills or propaganda of saying she was "unsinkable." They instead claimed "Lord and the officers on the Californian could have saved most or all lives." So people believed that instead of finding fault on The Board of Trade. It probably in Lord Mersey's stupid mind, suited much better to blame Lord than ruin several Board of Trade's members reputations.

-And Lord served on the Lawther Latta from 1913 to 1927 as a captain where he retired a wealthy man. I have no idea where you gathered that information from that he never made captain again.
_________________
"Looked like a rocket sir."

"Yes, I wonder why a ship like that would want to fire a rocket?"

(A Night to Remember, Stone & Gibson)
Posted on: 2007/6/4 2:49
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Titanic and the Californian torrence27 2007/4/15 5:17
       Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/4/15 17:57
         Re: Titanic and the Californian LeoPlumtree 2007/4/15 19:16
           Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/16 1:18
             Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/16 1:47
               Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/16 4:31
                 Re: Titanic and the Californian Captain Dan 2007/4/16 15:58
                   Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/16 18:36
                     Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/16 18:38
                       Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/24 22:21
                         Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/4/28 2:31
                           Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/30 0:17
                             Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/30 0:19
                               Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/4/30 4:06
                                 Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/5/2 20:34
                                   Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/5/3 0:11
                                     Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/5/3 0:59
                                       Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/5/3 20:33
                                         Re: Titanic and the Californian Rowan 2007/5/3 23:10
                                           Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/5/4 3:51
     Re: Titanic and the Californian Buff Egan 2007/5/30 14:00
       Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/5/30 20:57
         Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/5/30 23:19
           Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/5/30 23:20
             Re: Titanic and the Californian Buff Egan 2007/5/31 14:27
               Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/5/31 20:18
                 Re: Titanic and the Californian MGY Friend 2007/5/31 22:19
                   Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/6/1 1:02
                     Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/6/1 1:16
                       Re: Titanic and the Californian Buff Egan 2007/6/1 23:25
                         Re: Titanic and the Californian Danny J 2007/6/2 4:07
                         Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/6/4 2:49
                           Re: Titanic and the Californian MGY Friend 2007/6/4 18:56
                             Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/6/6 3:13
                               Re: Titanic and the Californian Buff Egan 2007/6/8 15:41
                                 Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/6/9 16:56
                                   Re: Titanic and the Californian Mac G 2007/7/26 23:28
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box