Main Menu
Recent News
Latest Articles
Random photos


Titanic.com - Titanic News, Photos, Articles & Research | Forum Index
   Titanic historic
   Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay?

Browsing this Thread:   60 Anonymous Users

 

  Bottom    Previous Topic    Next Topic
  •  Rate Thread
      Rate this Thread
      Excellent
      Good
      Average
      Bad
      Terrible
Poster Thread Rated:  4 Votes
  •  Mac G
      Mac G
Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay?
#1

Joined: 2007/4/15
From New York
Posts: -1
Group:
Registered Users
Offline
Well said my friend. I think we were talking a Phillips as well too!

Anyways, Ismay shares no relevance to a "bad guy" to myself. He just happened to own the White Star Line. Furthermore, why is he, or any other man labeled a coward for surviving? Life is a precise thing, if he could get in a boat with more spots for people, why not take it? Makes sense to me. If he was knocking people out of the way, held people at gun point to let him in, etc then I could see a true coward.


Lastly, thank you for bringing up Stanley Lord's name. I've been a "Lordist" (if that's what they call people who defend him) since I read up on it when I was 12-13 years old. The whole involvement with the Californian is complete and full of BS. Both Sen. Smith and Lord Mersy do not look into the full details of what actually happened. Their conclusions were very wrong as well. Mercy claims that the "Californian could have said most, if not all the lives." WOW. No way in the world a dinky vessel like the Californian would have been able to 1. Get there in time. 2. Have enough room for 2,220 souls + their crew. 3. No one on the Californian had any idea the ship was in distress, Stone himself said he didn't think the vessel was in danger. So it's not like they heard SOS and sat their. I also want everyone to know "The Californian had a capacity of 47 passengers and 55 crew members."

Lord and his crew(Groves, Stone, Evans, Gibson, Stewart, etc) were wrongfully accused and made a scapegoat of this whole disaster.

MGY, how great would it have been to be working on the bridge of the Californian on the middle watch? I would love to just go watch and observe what was seen and said between Groves, Stone, and Gibson. Little did these men know was they were witnessing the greatest maritime disaster of all-time.
_________________
"Looked like a rocket sir."

"Yes, I wonder why a ship like that would want to fire a rocket?"

(A Night to Remember, Stone & Gibson)
Posted on: 2007/11/26 3:23
Create PDF from Post Print
Top
Subject Poster Date
     Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Titanic_charlie 2007/11/15 22:19
       Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/11/16 20:32
         Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? MGY Friend 2007/11/16 21:51
           Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Titanic_charlie 2007/11/16 22:48
             Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/11/18 18:50
               Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? lilcandycane 2007/11/19 3:45
                 Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? MGY Friend 2007/11/19 16:02
                   Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Anonymous 2007/11/20 12:00
                     Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/11/20 17:20
                       Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? MGY Friend 2007/11/20 19:31
                         Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/11/26 3:23
                           Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/11/26 3:31
                             Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? MGY Friend 2007/11/26 23:07
                               Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/11/27 4:46
                                 Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/11/27 4:50
                                   Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/11/27 21:21
                                     Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? pianoprincess 2007/12/2 22:45
                                       Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/12/2 22:58
                                         Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/12/3 0:18
                                           Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/12/3 20:20
                                             Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/12/4 1:53
                                               Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/12/4 20:45
                                                 Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Mac G 2007/12/8 6:14
                                                   Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? <3 2007/12/9 4:15
                       Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? SimpsonsGod551 2007/12/27 5:09
       Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? SeaRiggs 2008/1/19 22:06
         Re: Thomas Andrews: Hero, or as guilty as Ismay? Anonymous 2008/2/17 17:31
 Top   Previous Topic   Next Topic

 


 You cannot start a new topic.
 You can view topic.
 You cannot reply to posts.
 You cannot edit your posts.
 You cannot delete your posts.
 You cannot add new polls.
 You cannot vote in polls.
 You cannot attach files to posts.
 You cannot post without approval.



Copyright © 2006-2012 Titanic.com
Home Photos Advertise Link to us Flower Box