I like A Night to Remember. But I don't compare it to the Cameron film based on the simple fact that both tackle the same story from totally different perspectives. The only complaints I could have against A Night to Remeber are its depiction of Baker Charles Jaughin as a stumbling drunk and the detached way in which they had Andrews tell Captain Smith that the ship was doomed. I'd imagine that a person who was so meticulous that he felt that there were "too few screws in the stateroom coat hooks" would be a little more affected by the fact that his creation was doomed.